Page 22 of 37
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 9:36 am
by dead_poet
PurpleMustReign wrote:Someone told me this morning that Harvin said he would hold out. Has he been quoted recently saying that?
Not recently. But that's been a foregone conclusion for about a year. Here's where I believe the hoopla originated:
Per a league source, Harvin currently is expected to stay away from offseason workouts and training camp absent a new deal.
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... rent-deal/
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 10:24 am
by dead_poet
Pretty solid column by Souhan.
Souhan: Volatile Harvin still brings more reward than risk
This is the NFL, and what we know for sure about Harvin is that he never has been indicted on double murder charges, doesn't get fat before realizing he needs NFL paychecks to pay off past bar bills, never plays at half-speed and has yet to speak out against the possibility of a gay teammate.
The Super Bowl featured players for whom the same can't be said. The Baltimore Ravens won the title while relying on Ray Lewis and Bryant McKinnie, beating a 49ers team that employs Randy Moss and homophobe cornerback Chris Culliver.
If those teams can win with those personalities, the Vikings can afford to gamble on a 24-year-old player at a position of great need who three months ago was considered one of the most valuable players in the league.
http://m.startribune.com/?id=190948781
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 10:30 am
by losperros
It's the best article I've read about Harvin and the Vikings so far. Souhan takes a practical and realistic view of the situation.
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 10:54 am
by mansquatch
That pretty much sums up my point of view. I think folks need to put Harvin into context. The media has labeled him a headcase/troublemaker mainly due to the fact that he hasn’t just towed the company line at all times. He hasn’t done anything near Randy Moss level antics. One fit on the sidelines in a game where he had plenty of reason to melt down, a couple reported outbursts in the locker room, what am I missing? IMO, all of that could easily be considered Harvin’s passion to win vs. his being a total cancer. What Cook pulled last year was far worse for the team as a whole than anything Harvin has done. I think part of this is the fact that the Superbowl was 2 weeks ago and now Reporters need to get by for 5 months before there is once again a steady drip of NFL news.
The ice needs to melt, time to go fishing!
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 10:57 am
by Mothman
The problem is those examples are straw men with no real connection to what's happening in the Vikings/Harvin situation. IF there's genuine concern about Harvin's attitude in the Vikings camp, it probably has more to do with undermining authority and creating dissension than with comments to the media that have nothing to do with football or involve criminal exploits (of which, if I'm not mistaken, there are no reports related to Harvin). There's no real indication from the Vikes that they are genuinely concerned about any of this stuff. Frazier sounds like he loves Harvin and wants him back. Spielman sounds like he'd like to have him back too, although as always, when a contract is up in the air, he's not saying too much.
Souhan focused on Harvin's talent and on the potential character concerns in this situation but as we discussed yesterday, it's the money that's probably the real issue. I'm pretty sure the Vikings understand what kind of talent they have in Harvin. Until we know what and how much Harvin is demanding and whether or not the Vikings have even made an offer yet, it's hard for me to form a strong opinion on exactly what the best move is for the team. Heck, do we even know if negotiations have been going on? Have they started or broken off ? There's been no statement from either camp yet one story is just feeding off another and speculation, opinion, etc. is ricocheting around.
Souhan's right, the rewards Harvin offers are worth risk but the problem here is nobody knows the stakes.
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 12:16 pm
by PurpleMustReign
No. I want all pussies and angels on my Vikings. If someone so much as curses on the field, get rid of them. In fact, lets sign Tebow so we can properly pray before every game and practice.
Sent from my SGH-T769 using Tapatalk 2
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 1:01 pm
by dead_poet
Percy Harvin - WR - Vikings
A Vikings team source said he doesn't "think we should be at the point of being done with" Percy Harvin.
"He is a star athlete who is a great player," the source told ESPN's Josina Anderson. "Is he a volatile guy? Yes. Can he be managed? Yes. For me he is not an issue. You just have to be able to deal and manage star players." This is the wisest assessment of the Harvin situation we've seen yet. The Vikings would be crazy to sell one of the game's most valuable players for pennies on the dollar -- even if he is threatening to stage a holdout.
Source: Josina Anderson on Twitter
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 1:53 pm
by losperros
mrc44 wrote:But at the same time both of those teams are coached by some of the strongest minded and outspoken coaches in the league... we don't have a coach like that. We have a calm quiet coach that obviously handles situations differently. Do I like Frazier? yes I think he is awesome, but he just doesn't seem like the type of coach that can be the leader of players with ego's.
Frazier just doesnt have that fire that I see in the Harbaughs. Thats jmo
Point well taken and Souhan does cover what a NFL coach's responsibility should be in his article, and he basically does say the Vikings staff should be able to handle a temperamental guy like Harvin.
Thus far I respect Frazier a lot. I think that Frazier's calming influence and ability to listen to his players (instead of rant at them like Childress did) might actually be a strength for the team. Let's keep this in mind. Frazier has already stated in public that he wants Harvin on the team and not playing for another team. If nothing else, Frazier has laid his cards on the table. I think that shows some leadership.
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 2:16 pm
by chicagopurple
Harvin's biggest limitation is that he lacks a QB to throw him the ball. He knows it and , as a WR, finds it frustrating. I think he is just being really honest. A WR has a limited career, and if he spends it waiting on the QB to grow up and get his head straight, his career might be over. I think the whole Harvin thing isa realdistraction from the very serious question the Vikes have at the QB position. NONE of current WR greats in the league would be happy with Ponder this year. He would make them all look worse.
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 2:19 pm
by Cliff
chicagopurple wrote:Harvin's biggest limitation is that he lacks a QB to throw him the ball. He knows it and , as a WR, finds it frustrating. I think he is just being really honest. A WR has a limited career, and if he spends it waiting on the QB to grow up and get his head straight, his career might be over. I think the whole Harvin thing isa realdistraction from the very serious question the Vikes have at the QB position. NONE of current WR greats in the league would be happy with Ponder this year. He would make them all look worse.
Harvin was on track to have his best season thus far with Ponder throwing him the ball ...
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 2:46 pm
by chicagopurple
ponder had a burst of sucess but it was rather short lived, and he steadily regressed as the season went on.
I just am trying to look at it from a pro WR viewpoint...given the choice, if I was a top ranked reciever, I wouldn't want to spend my prime years waiting for a prospect to grow up if I could move to a team with a great QB......
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 3:17 pm
by dead_poet
Percy Harvin - WR - Vikings
According to a "high-ranking Vikings source," Percy Harvin "expects" an extension similar to the deals recently signed by Calvin Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald.
The league's two highest paid receivers, Johnson scored an eight-year, $150.5 million pact last March, while Fitzgerald is entering year three of an eight-year, $128.5 million deal. Megatron's deal includes $60 million guaranteed, Fitz's $50 million. If true, it would certainly explain why the Vikings are at least exploring trading a player who's among the most gifted in the league, but also hot-headed with health question marks. However, it's extremely doubtful Harvin could even approach Fitz and Mega's deals, in Minnesota or elsewhere. We're likely only at the beginning of a long and winding ordeal.
Source: ESPN.com
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 3:25 pm
by Purple bruise
mrc44 wrote:
HAHAHHA, that's funny that you say he regressed. Did he have a slump midway through the season? yes. but did he regress as the season went on? no. He had one of his best games of his career against Green Bay and it was at the end of the season, and it was with out Percy Harvin. So IMO you are wrong.
As far as spending it with a QB growing, I disagree with that as well. Larry Fitzgerald is not complaining in Arizona, and the reason is because HE GOT PAID! Harvin probably cares less where he plays if he gets PAID. In fact I guarantee he would would rather play in Minnesota if he was paid, because he is familiar with the play book and it is centered around HIM and AP.
Ponder helped Percy almost reach the best year of his career, yet PH got injured and was out half of the season. Where PH does best (like Mothman and I had said earlier) is in the screens, when he is given the ball quick and early so he can just destroy the defense with his speed and agility. In that case what does it matter what the QB is capable of? If the QB can throw 5 yards then he should be able to get the ball to PH.
Also, I don't think that Ponder is as bad as a lot of people think he is. I think that his ability to throw down field and longer post routes, was crippled by the horrible WR's we had on this team. And proof of that came around once Wright was put in the game to stretch the field. I fyou go back and look at those deep throws, the majority of them are BEAUTIFUL. I bet you the 2013 season, as long as we get some LEGIT WR help, will be completely different.
All we need is weapons around Ponder and he will play a great deal better. Here is what I think we should do this offseason with our WR corps;
release AromashaPOO, JOKEns, Burtin.
Resign Jerome Simpson to a 1 year deal for back up purposes, along with the fact that our QB is requesting it.
Resign PH to a nice contract (maybe 7 million per year for 5 years, with 15 million guaranteed)
Draft Patterson or Allen in the 1st or draft Hopkins, Williams, Patton, or Woods in the 2nd
Draft Aaron Dobson in the 4th
So now we have.. Percy Harvin, Jarius Wright, Jerome Simpson, Aaron Dobson (6'3 205lbs, 4.33 sec 40) and then say Hopkins (just for fun). That is one helluva WR corps in my opinion!! Teh last guy needed can come from late in the draft or from practice squad.
I like your plan

There are, if you hadn't noticed yet several fans that will take nearly any post and turn it into a bashing opprotunity towards Ponder. I take it for what it is worth

Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 3:28 pm
by Cliff
dead_poet wrote:
Percy Harvin - WR - Vikings
According to a "high-ranking Vikings source," Percy Harvin "expects" an extension similar to the deals recently signed by Calvin Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald.
The league's two highest paid receivers, Johnson scored an eight-year, $150.5 million pact last March, while Fitzgerald is entering year three of an eight-year, $128.5 million deal. Megatron's deal includes $60 million guaranteed, Fitz's $50 million. If true, it would certainly explain why the Vikings are at least exploring trading a player who's among the most gifted in the league, but also hot-headed with health question marks. However, it's extremely doubtful Harvin could even approach Fitz and Mega's deals, in Minnesota or elsewhere. We're likely only at the beginning of a long and winding ordeal.
Source: ESPN.com
Hopefully he doesn't actually think he should get paid that kind of money and it's just the first step in a negotiation.
We'll see ...
Re: Percy's future w/ Vikings looking uncertain
Posted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 3:46 pm
by Cliff
That would put him making more than Peterson, wouldn't it?