It's not a very high bar to set.dead_poet wrote:I don't know. But I'm assuming their methodology is the same for all QBs. Even if there is a +/- error of a few percentage points, it's still an encouraging stat and I won't let you belittle it! I know you're comparing stats to Ponder below, but this stat for Teddy's rookie year beats Ponder's for any year of his career. Reason for optimism for me.
Sorry... just kidding. I actually thought about your point above and should have mentioned it in my post. Hopefully PFF is at least relatively consistent with their methodology which still means Bridgewater scored well against his peers and that's encouraging.
I really don't want to go down that road, at least not any further than I did.If you want to go down the Bridgewater vs. Ponder road, you should also probably highlight the fact that Bridgewater's season completion percentage was a full 10 percentage points higher than Ponder's (64% vs. 54%) on 111 more attempts.
It's OK, Dem..er...Jim. You clearly only want the Vikings to improve (desperately). I think you're just getting a bit fed up with all of the mediocrity (to sub-par) seasons since 2009. Nobody can blame you there. But you do seem a bit more curmudgeony for Bridgewater and his first year than what I recall your tone of Ponder and his. Just an observation.
Guilty as charged, although I prefer to think of my attitude as pragmatic rather than "more curmudgeony". I think I'm just responding to what's around me. When I felt people were being too quick to declare Ponder a bust after one season, I encouraged them to be patient and keep an open mind. Now, the more I'm surrounded by hype about Bridgewater after one season, I find myself also preaching patience but in a more cautionary sense. I'm probably too pragmatic for my own good but as you said, I'm fed up with mediocrity and if I'm honest with myself, probably not eager to get my hopes too high and have them dashed by the Vikes again.
Bridgewater had a solid season for a rookie but in the end, in terms of the overall quality of NFL QB play, it was a pretty mediocre season. I'm trying not to lose perspective on that. It was his first season so I'm not saying I expected more than that from him, nor am I implying that I'm fed up with Bridgewater just because I'm fed up with mediocrity. At this point, waving decent QB play in front of Vikes fans is like waving a steak in front of a starving dog so I understand the response to his performance. I'm attempting to keep it in perspective.