808vikingsfan wrote: ↑Sun Apr 26, 2020 7:55 pm
If we are all fine with 9-7, 10-6, one and done in the playoffs, let's never take a chance on another QB and extend Cousins until forever.
So since that’s what Kirk did this year are you saying he hit his ceiling and can’t do better than 10-6 or win more than 1 game in the playoffs? I mean he’s been here for 2 years, not 8. If that’s what you’re saying then it’s nothing but pure speculation.
And sorry but you’re just trying to egg people on saying “let’s just extend cousins until forever”. Nobody is saying that, you know nobody is saying that, so why say it?
I mean if you look at every starting QB in the nfl this is what you have:
Jets: Darnold- 1st round
Bills: Allen- 1st
Dolphins: Tua - 1st
Patriots: Stidham- 4th
Steelers: Roethlisberger- 1st
Ravens: Jackson- 1st
Browns: Mayfield- 1st
Bengals: Burrow- 1st
Jaguars: Minshew- 6th
Titans: Tannehill- 1st
Colts: Rivers- 1st
Texans: Watson- 1st
Chiefs: Mahomes- 1st
Raiders: Carr- 2nd
Chargers: Herbert- 1st
Broncos: Lock- 2nd
Eagles: Wentz- 1st
Redskins: Haskins- 1st
Giants: Jones- 1st
Cowboys: Prescott- 3rd
Vikings: Cousins- 4th
Bears: Trubisky- 1st
Lions: Stafford- 1st
Packers: Rodgers- 1st
Falcons: Ryan- 1st
Saints: Brees- 1st
Bucs: Brady- 6th
Panthers: Bridgewater- 1st
Rams: Goff- 1st
49ers: Garoppolo- 2nd
Cardinals: Murray- 1st
Seahawks: Wilson- 3rd
So in the end,
23 of 32 QBs in the nfl are 1st round picks
3 of 32 are 2nd round
2 of 32 are 3rd round
2 of 32 is 4th round
0 of 32 are 5th round
2 of 32 are 6th round
0 of 32 are 7th round
So outside of the first round, there are 9 of 32 QBs in the nfl are non-first round QBs. Those QBs are:
Stidham
Minshew
Lock
Prescott
Cousins
Brady
Garoppolo
Wilson
How many are any good? 4-5 of them? If you’re drafting a QB in rounds 2-7, the chances of you hitting on that player are MUCH lower than if you take one in the first. How often are QBs taken in round 2-7 ever successful? So many fans want some “developmental” guy and all this bologna. To develop into what? Like yeah sure there is a
chance but it’s very slim unless you take one in the first round that this guy “develops” into a legitimate starter.
So I guess my point is, given how good this draft was for us, what are you complaining about? Because we didn’t take James Morgan in the 4th round? If you thought we should’ve actually take a QB in the first round who would that have been? Do you realize what it would’ve cost to trade up to even #6 to get Herbert?? We would’ve had glaring holes all over this team if we tried doing that. Jordan love was not worthy of a 1st round pick. It was up to the big 3 if we really wanted a shot a someone. And Tua and Herbert also have giant question marks. Most starting caliber QBs come out of the 1st round. We’d have to trade up a boatload for it to POSSIBLY be worth it. I’m sorry but nobody outside of Burrow in this class was worth that. And making a trade for Burrow would have put us so far behind it wouldn’t even be realistically possible.
Nobody is saying we should never look for a QB and just stick with cousins forever but not only was this class not worth it or a huge trade not worth it but we also had much bigger shoes to fill all over this roster. There is very little, if anything, to complain about in this draft. Actual performance aside, this draft was excellent in just about any way you could think of and I would think most would agree on that. Just because you don’t like cousins and don’t want him on this team doesn’t mean we should address the QB position every year while he is here.