Try to look at this from the perspective of the kicker.Purple Martin wrote: ↑Tue Aug 20, 2019 9:15 pm I'm confused. How does the fact that Bailey has hit 75% in camp with a VARIETY of holders prove that the holder matters? I need a head-scratching emo here. Doesn't sucking with a variety of holders only prove that the kicker sucks?
According to several articles I've read on the subject, it takes three things to happen for a field goal to have a good chance of being successful.
1. The long snapper needs to put the ball not only on the money to the holder, but also at the correct velocity, and he's got to spin it so that the holder gets the ball and can just set it down without having to rotate the laces.
2. The holder needs to place the ball at the correct angle and with the right amount of pressure. He can't be slow about it.
3. The kicker needs to execute the kick.
All of this needs to happen with precise timing. For punts, the standard in the NFL is 0.7 to 0.8 seconds for a snap to travel 15 yards, which is about 40 mph. Anything faster, and the punter has trouble catching it. Anything slower, and you run the risk of a punt block. I'm not sure of the timing for field goals, but I'd be shocked if it wasn't just as precise. Kevin McDermott has been quoted as saying that when he was in college, you could miss by a foot, and nobody would care as long as the holder could catch it. In the NFL, if he's off by a couple of inches, or it's not perfect in any way, he hears about it. They work very hard to learn to snap the ball the exact same way every time.
If you've got a rotating group of holders, all doing it just a little bit different (slightly different angles, one places the ball a fraction of a second slower than another guy, etc.) can you see how that might affect the kicker's performance?
Add in the fact that the Vikings were using two long snappers until last week, and you've got variables in two of the three elements of a successful kick. That's tough for a kicker.
Zimmer has said over and over that they need to stabilize the situation so they can get the snapper, holder and kicker in sync.
Hope that helps.