I'll say it: Zero Credibility. Are they really such experts? Who are they specifically? What is their track record? Most importantly: What are their current results? Want to test them? Take your current copy of Madden and see how it ranks the best teams. The go look at the standings and see how they did. I bet Dallas, currently sitting at 6-6, is a top 5 or even top 3 team in your precious game. Dallas is not going to make the playoffs this year.allday1991 wrote: Lol so a group of people basing a video game off the sport we are talking about isn't relevant? Zero credibility? Just cause its a video game? I'll explain this again players rating are based off a panel vote which is aimed to be as unbiased as possible. Even if they didnt under cut Kendricks abit he isnt no 99. The fact that these two are being compared to Luke just reinforces the fact your being bias. I showed you a group (big group) of people that agree with me but you dismiss it because its a video game? Then say Kendricks is top 5 with no backing at all? Take off the glasses, it might not be the best source but it is worth more than a bunch of bias fans towards their teams.
Just because something has a lot of marketing backing and media backing (read the business spent $$$ on Advertising) doesn't mean it is a be all, end all, expert. Look at the results on the field. Ask yourself why so many on here are commenting on how BAD the media broadcasters are. In that ATL game the Fox Broadcasters gushed about Julio Jones for 3 and 2/3 Quarters even though during the whole game he had 2 catches for twenty some yards. If they were such experts as their perch IMPLIES then they should have been talking about the guy preventing him from doing ANYTHING.
Another consideration is what is the aim of the madden title? Is it to be the most accurate representation of the NFL or is it to sell copies of the video game? Perhaps Kuechly is a 99 since they feel he is a more popular player even if he not actually a better player. Is that marketing or is that reality?
Look at the results someone achieves before you crown them an expert. Otherwise in today's world you will constantly be two steps behind.